Commentary: David Robertson
Win luxury hampers plus Waitrose vouchers & guidebooks
Landing slots at Heathrow are so valuable that companies can spend years and millions of pounds negotiating to get only one aircraft into the airport.
Heathrow, the world’s busiest international airport, is so constrained in the number of flights it can accommodate that an airline wanting to set up operations there can pay up to £30 million for a good pair of take-off and landing times. When Continental Airlines, the American carrier, wanted to start operations from Heathrow this year it had to spend more than £100 million on only four slots, and there are rumours that other carriers have paid much more.
As a result, airlines jealously hoard their slots and in some cases these landing rights have become more valuable than the companies themselves. However, there is a “use-it-or-lose-it” rule in operation at Heathrow, so an airline such as bmi, the former British Midland, must keep flying to hold on to its slots - even if its aircraft are virtually empty.
It is, therefore, better for a carrier such as bmi to lose £20,000 per flight than to give up a £30 million slot. For bmi this is particularly important as it is trying to keep its value up for a potential sale this year. British Airways, Virgin Atlantic and Lufthansa are all interested in buying bmi, and the biggest attraction is the airline’s 11 per cent of Heathrow slots - the second-largest holding behind BA.
However, some aviation analysts believe that there are no legal grounds for these carriers to own the slots, and advocate that they should belong to the State and be leased to the highest bidder. High prices for rented slots would encourage only profitable flights, which would almost certainly mean full flights.
BA has also operated uneconomical flights from Heathrow in the past but has moved to a more efficient and flexible use of its landing times to get around the use-it-or-lose-it rule. Rising fuel costs, however, could make it more likely that the airline will sporadically cancel unpopular flights. Regular travellers on shuttle routes such as Heathrow to Edinburgh or Manchester have long suspected that BA cancels flights if there are not enough people on board, but this is likely to become a more regular event.
Passengers may have to get used to being stranded by airlines that do not want to lose money by transporting them.
Search for a holiday
e.g. Villa in Tuscany
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers


Free luxury travel brochures from specialist tour operators. Find your perfect holiday. Live the dream.
Find a holiday rental at Times Online, villas, apartments and much more

Paulc, I find the idea of subletting quite interesting. However, I guess they would have done it if they could. Also why dont they sell those empty spaces in planes at a bargain like Taxes+1 gbp, they would still have that, full planes and even profit as ppl would carry on buying stuff in the plane.
Will, Madrid, Spain
BA wouldnt be worth tuppence without the value of landing slots at heathrow? you dont think the fact that they are one of very few profitable airlines in the world has anything to do with their value?
and just owning slots at heathrow doesnt gurantee sucess, you still need profits.
Will, grimsby, uk
Clearly Heathrow doesn't need a third runway: it needs to overhaul the pricing of the existing two. This is a classic case of a pricing inefficiency (effectively a subsidy for those airlines that are "awarded" landing slots) leading to irrational behaviour.
Jay, Luxembourg,
It's all part of the BA /BAA scam. BA/Virgin/BMI wouldn't be worth tuppence without them. Any other government would control landing and take off slots through a public body. This government which is so quick to rape the public through petrol duty, gives it to the airlines tax and duty free.
Del, Chesterfield, UK
And how much money does Heathrow take each time a plane lands??
It's these bids that are causing over inflated prices, yes, oil to an extent but these numbers are ludicrous!
Jonathan, Malvern, UK
Heathrow slots are a licence to print money. They are why Branson and Virgin Atlantic worked and Laker failed. Branson has never succeeded with a competitive business, Virgin Cola anyone?
Jon, London,
can't they "sublet" the slots? that way they get to keep their investment, don't have to fly empty planes and someone else can use the slot who actually wants it...
paulc, gloucester,